Alan and Walden go to Kate's fashion show in New York so Walden can reveal the truth about his identity.
No sooner has Wallace rejoined the Hearst basketball team than the coach Tom Barry (MATT McKENZIE) is found dead. The coach's widow Kathleen (recurring guest star TRACEY NEEDHAM) hires Keith to investigate the murder of her husband and to clear her son Josh (recurring guest star JONATHAN CHASE) who is the prime suspect. Meanwhile Logan wallows in self-pity after his breakup with Veronica so Dick (recurring guest star RYAN HANSEN) invites two girls over to cheer him up. Unfortunately Logan is stuck entertaining Heather (JULIETTE GOGLIA) who is only 13 years old. Also Keith and Veronica discover that the alibis given by Mindy O'Dell (recurring guest star JAMIE RAY NEWMAN) and Professor Landry (recurring guest star PATRICK FABIAN) do not match.
The team caters a senior singles mixer hosted by Pepper McMasters; Constance has an awkward encounter.