When the guys camp in line for a screening, their plans are thwarted by Sheldon's greatest nemesis, WIL WHEATON (guest starring as himself). Meanwhile, Penny and Bernadette invite Amy to her first slumber party.
Max attempts to make a good impression on her first day of pastry school, but finds the class clown, Deke (recurring guest star ERIC ANDRÉ – The Internship, Don't Trust the B---- in Apartment 23), to be extremely distracting — and intriguing. Meanwhile, Caroline dresses to impress Max's handsome teacher, Nicolas (recurring guest star GILLES MARINI). Recurring guest star MARY LYNN RAJSKUB also appears as Bebe.
When Deke (recurring guest star ERIC ANDRÉ) takes Max to his place after a great first date, his "home" is nothing like she expected. Meanwhile, Caroline feels empowered — then scared for her life — after having a suspicious car towed from in front of their apartment building.
When Nicolas (recurring guest star GILLES MARINI) invites Caroline to a dinner date at his loft, she asks Max and Deke (recurring guest star ERIC ANDRÉ) to join her to help make sure she doesn't do anything she might regret. Also, Max and Caroline treat themselves to very special hair appointments.
Max decides to break up with Deke (recurring guest star ERIC ANDRÉ) now that she knows about his wealthy background.