Gabrielle Allan

A string of bad luck ensues when Ted picks up a lucky penny; Marshall's injured toe keeps him out of the New York City Marathon.

J.D.(Zach Braff) is torn when he discovers that Dr. Cox (John C. McGinley) has falsely appropriated the medical insurance of a deceased patient in order to help another more needy patient but when he inadvertently informs Cox' rival -- the nasty Dr. Kelso (Ken Jenkins) -- the two veteran doctors battle for J.D.'s soul during a good-vs.-evil game of golf. Meanwhile, Turk (Donald Faison) frets that his girlfriend Carla (Judy Reyes) might figure out where he got his new gift for her. Sarah Chalke also stars. Louie Anderson ("Family Feud") guest-stars as himself.

J.D. (Zach Braff) decides he won't start dating again until Elliot (Sarah Chalke) does, but doesn't expect the person she starts dating to be his brother Dan (guest star Tom Cavanagh), who's still sticking around after the recent death of their father. When J.D. catches them sleeping together in the on-call room, things get a little awkward between the three. Meanwhile, after Turk (Donald Faison) is diagnosed with Type II Diabetes, he milks every ounce of sympathy out of his friends. Elsewhere, Dr. Cox (John C. McGinley) and Dr. Kelso (Ken Jenkins) get fed-up with Molly's (guest star Heather Graham) perception that everyone is good at heart and seek to prove her wrong. Judy Reyes and Neil Flynn also star.