S1, E3: Sailing from the Island of Nautia in pursuit of the treasure ship 'Esperance' a raft is sighted with a man onboard waving the skull and crossbones. The pirates take him onboard the 'Charming Molly' to discover he is Mr Trumpet, one of the crew of the 'Esperance' who claims to have been a mutineer. The crew of the 'Charming Molly' plan their own mutiny against the man they believe to be their captain. A mutiny is averted by Jack who is warned in time by Mr Trumpet. Still believing Judge Sharringham to be his twin brother Captain Sharringham, Jack claims their bargain is near complete. The 'Charming Molly' encounters the treasure ship 'Esperance', but in the raging seas, the two ships collide.