Andy invites the entire office to his community theatre production of Sweeney Todd in hopes that Erin will attend. Michael tries to put his jealousy aside and enjoy the performance while Jim and Pam struggle with their incompetent babysitter.
When Andy decides to throw a garden party at Schrute Farms to impress Robert, Dwight researches how to be a good host. Unfortunately, Andy's family end up making him feel self-conscious.
A possible work promotion interferes with Jess' excitement for jury duty, Cece's messiness pushes Nick over the edge.