Trey Carlisle

Upon discovering that he is the holder of a winning ticket, Earl is hit by a car and the ticket blows out of his limp hand as he lies unconscious in the street. While recovering in the hospital and watching television, Earl has a karmic epiphany.

During their high school days, Earl ruined Randy's chance to score a touchdown during a key American football game, so Earl tries to figure out a way to make things right.

Catalina helps Earl atone for number 75 on his list: Used the mailbox as a trash can. Clearing out the mailbox, they find two undelivered letters: one that reveals secrets of Darnell's mysterious past to a shocked Joy, and a love letter that never reached its intended recipient, leading to humiliation for the sender. However, Earl's attempts to make amends are hampered by his attraction to the love letter's addressee.

Earl's list of misdeeds grows when Joy makes it very clear that he's not welcome at her wedding to Darnell, scheduling it for his birthday so that no one can celebrate with him. This leaves him with just one possible course of action.

Earl tries to win a beauty pageant trophy for Joy to make up for breaking one that she had won, so he enlists the help of her former nemesis, but Joy wants to stay on Earl's list so that he will owe her a hot tub.