S1, E2: Teenager Nicole Holt (guest star Skyler Day) and Chris Ellis (guest star Brad Beyer) are questioned after witnessing a slashing, but the duo lies about how much they saw - and who they really are. While Virgil (Pablo Schreiber) and Teddy (Neal Bledsoe) are on the serial killer's trail, Ironside (Blair Underwood) and Holly (Spencer Grammer) investigate a case-within-a-case when they uncover the teenager went missing as a child.