A young man named Ethan (Daniel Letterle) is head-over-heels in love with an ex-baseball player (Diego Serrano) who has just revealed in a new book that he is gay. Meanwhile, a former lover (David Monahan) plots to sell Ethan's house, prompting him to enlist the aid of a hot guy (Dean Shelton) and a real-estate agent (Rebecca Lowman) to prevent the sale from going through.