Facing official reprimand from Frank, Jamie refuses to explain why he contests the arrest report of a fellow officer who was assaulted in the field; Danny and Baez clash when their lead suspect for a murder is one of Danny's favourite comics.
Marnie tries to convince Desi to follow through with their planned gig at her mother's birthday party; Hannah gets advice on an important decision from her father and his new partner; Elijah helps a co-worker run lines for an audition.
When a businessman is murdered, his surprising connection to Cosgrove's daughter helps the police make a break in the case; Price and Maroun disagree on how to proceed at trial when the defendant's age brings up legal precedent they must follow.
Gordon travels to Miami to persuade Carmine Falcone to help in the fight against Penguin. Carmine's daughter Sofia follows Gordon back to Gotham. Bruce is put on Penguin's radar during an auction at the Iceberg Lounge.
Donna wants to become friends with a couple in church, but Kevin is reluctant. Kevin warms to him after learning that the man is a chiropractor for some New York Mets players and offers him and Donna the chance to stay at his Florida condo.