Three families are recorded in their homes; Tam catches Paul texting his ex, reopening old wounds; Deena realizes Andy's affair has strained her relationship with her daughters; Mandy is too exhausted from raising four kids to find time for Jeff.
Tam looks for clues from Madame Julie's card reading and finds an unlikely answer; Deena confesses to Chelsi only to find she already knew the truth; Mandy fights to keep afloat as her youngest boy rocks the boat.
In New York, Deena is dreading Andy's birthday because the whole family knows he was unfaithful; in Florida, Paul gaslights Tam, throwing her into a frenzy before therapy; in Illinois, the devil is trying to ruin Mandy and Jeff's dinner party.
Tam and Paul have a couples reading that reveals Paul must make a choice; Deena has Savannah's boyfriend over for dinner to get to know him; Mandy adjusts to her rigorous schedule at home with four kids.
Tam and Paul get ready for the annual costume party that always ends in disaster; Andy is enraged when Deena's hurt feelings threaten their business partnership; Jeff helps Mandy get a break, only to realize how hard her days really are.
Paul stumbles back into Tam's life, testing her resolve to say goodbye; Andy must make a major sacrifice to save his marriage with Deena; Jeff and Mandy take a night off to try to reignite their passion.
