When a quiet young Idaho schoolteacher named Kacy Ray is found stabbed to death on a remote country road, investigators are hard-pressed to find anyone with a motive to do her harm. But in the tiny town of Burley, the rumors begin to fly - and police soon have a promising lead on who killed her.

In the small town of Ohio, Evelyn Howard, a 72 year-old grandmother has gone missing. Police are left with only cryptic and ominous clues as to what might have happened. Howard's mattress is missing and blood is found in her bedroom. Investigators chase every lead but it seems Evelyn has simply vanished. But then, police get a tip that turns this missing persons case into a murder investigation

When 24 year-old Tameka Huston goes missing, her hometown of Spartanburg South Carolina goes on high alert. Everyone seems to have a tip about the missing woman, and investigators soon have their hands full running down leads. Before long, their suspicions settle on Huston's boyfriend - but with no crime scene and no body, the investigation stalls.

Law student Doug Norwood is a man with no enemies, or so he thinks. But when someone tries to murder him twice, his girlfriend Cathy has a hunch who it could be: her ex-husband. Neither Cathy nor Doug has any proof, however, and police in the small university town of Fayetteville Arkansas refuse to take Norwood's claims seriously.

In a small Wisconsin town, investigators must solve a baffling mystery. Three members of the Krnak family and their dog have all vanished. The detective's only link to the missing family is the oldest son, Andrew. And police soon realize that this is not a typical missing persons case. There's something more sinister at work.

At a Forth of July party in the small town of Traveler's Rest, SC, twenty-year-old Brooke Henson is young and pretty with her whole life ahead of her. But after a fight with her boyfriend, Brooke walks away and vanishes without a trace. And police are left with only witnesses who have conflicting stories and foggy memories.