Catarina enjoys the school festival and gets a confession from Nicol. Maria proposes that Catarina join the Department of Magic.

One of the actors in the play being put on by the student council is injured; the search is on for an emergency stand-in; as the opening of the curtain draws closer, Catarina ends up agreeing to fill the role at Sophia's request.

Catarina is kidnapped by someone on her way to the ball; after awakening in an unfamiliar room, she struggles to fully grasp her situation and doesn't seem to realize she's been kidnapped.

Rufus tells Catarina the whole truth and shares stories about his childhood; Ian confesses his feelings to Selena.

Following Catarina's kidnapping, the first prince, Jeffrey Stuart, tells Susanna of his love for his younger brothers; Geordo and Alan reminisce about their childhood days with their older brothers.

Geordo invites Catarina to his family vacation home during summer vacation, but much to his annoyance, Alan has also invited their friends over as well.