Brooke Mackenzie

Ted is humiliated when he sees a woman he's dating out on another date on the night they'd planned to meet up; Marshall is charmed by a man who is smitten with Lily.

Alan is forced to put up with Eldgridge, Jake's troublesome new friend, and can't tell Eldridge's mum the truth. Later, he's surprised to learn that Charlie doesn't approve of his decision.

Chris' classmates do not take him seriously when he signs up to be a hall monitor; Tonya discovers that her friends hang out with her to get closer to Drew.