The team travels to Ohio in the hopes of tracking down a serial killer preying on married couples. Agent Hotchner considers a team member to fill a vacant role.
A 23-year-old man must enlist his family to help him raise a baby that is the result of a one-night stand with a wanted felon.
Earl fills in at a fast food restaurant to help a newlywed couple go on their honeymoon and learns that the boss is a bully.
Earl goes to dig up some buried historic silverware he stole from the town library with Joy and Randy, but it's not there. Randy recounts the story of where he moved it, while Joy discusses her attempt to melt the silverware.
Earl takes Joy's side in an argument between her and Darnell, and ends up involved in Joy's scheme to purchase an entertainment centre.