The BAU respond to a call from Virginia to investigate a child abductor who may have been keeping children for more than eight years.
The school therapist advises Frankie and Mike to get Brick a small pet, to help his interactions with people, but his new bunny is a bit of a prickly customer.
Brick works as a newspaper delivery boy for a veteran newsman; Sue does everything to convince herself that a long-distance relationship with Matt will work.
Brick encounters a series of misfortunes after finding a four-leaf clover. Meanwhile, Axl's friend asks Sue to the prom.
When the kids confront Frankie and Mike about their parenting style, they decide to change their ways. However, the outcome is quite unexpected.