Finch's cover is blown due to a fatal error, which leads to an escalating series of encounters with Samaritan's operatives.
Michael seeks to disclose the morality of Eleanor's past life by interrogating Eleanor and her friends at the neighbourhood; Chidi must come to terms with his moral dilemma of harbouring a secret.
An unprecedented circumstance tests Michael's abilities; Chidi makes a new connection with the other Eleanor; Eleanor gets a taste of what things are like in the Bad Place from the real Eleanor.
John Oliver discusses the presidential election in the Philippines, the recent North Korean Workers Party meeting, and the media's connection to junk science.
Detective Cullen decides that it might be for the best to finally split with Tolbeck. A surprise visitor unsettles car 27.