After getting back home from the police station, Stacey and Keith discover their daughter Day is gone; Keith interrogates Stacey about Day's location, but Stacey's memory disorder causes her to forget things; Tony teams up with Lisa to find Day.

Tony brings Day home and interrogates Stacey about her past with Keith and Karen; Stacey tells Tony that Karen and Keith dated back in high school; Tony tells Stacey about a boy named Kevin, claiming to be Day's brother.

Tony returns to the location where she and Stacey buried Karen and finds out from a phone call that Karen is still alive; Tony and Stacey try to figure out with help from Lisa who is helping Karen and if it could be Zeke, the detective.