In the premiere episode, Jack "Murf the Surf" Murphy's life takes a turn from childhood prodigy and professional surfing champion to notorious jewel thief when he pulls off the heist of the century in 1964.

After serving 21 months in prison for his jewel heist, Murf emerges with a hardened attitude and his crimes turn more violent. But when he gets involved in a securities scheme gone awry, he becomes the prime suspect after two women turn up dead.

Serving a double-life prison sentence for murder, Murf finds God and is reborn as a Christian. And God may just be his way out of the big house. But has Murf really changed his ways, or is this just another one of his cons?

Fresh out of prison, Murf the Surf embarks on his new path as a man of God. But as he attempts to convince the public that he is a reformed Christian, new facts emerge that challenge Murf's story of his life…and who he claims to be.