Ten years after Mitchell McDeere exposed his law firm as a mob front, the McDeeres leave witness protection and begin the difficult task of rebuilding their lives.

As Judge Trott decides whether to try Donnell Heywood as an adult or juvenile, the murdered boy's father seeks his own brand of justice. Mitch and Ray try to intervene before more tragedy results.

Mitch must defend the son of a partner in his new firm against a murder charge. As Mitch begins working on the Sarah Holt case, he starts to understand why Kinross & Grant brought him on.

Mitch defends a psychiatrist accused of killing her stalker. Mitch tells Abby and the FBI that he feels like he is being watched. Ray and Tammy work on the Sarah Holt case.

Mitch defends a gambler who insists that he is not guilty of murder. Mitch and Abby enlist Kinross & Grant to help them with the Althea Sanderson tort case.

Mitch discovers ulterior motives when a judge offers leniency for his client. Claire tries to convince her parents she needs a cell phone. Tammy and Ray continue working on the Sarah Holt case.