Jess struggles to keep the loft’s Secret Santa gift exchange afloat. When Winston believes his online gift order for Cece won’t be delivered in time he and Schmidt must endure going to an actual store to find a replacement gift. Meanwhile Reagan surprises Nick who helps makes Jess’ Christmas one to remember.
The gang takes a look at the gun ownership process and alternatives to find a common ground on this heated issue.
Matt asks someone to be his "plus one" at Wilhelmina's fundraiser; Daniel hires Natalie to be his assistant, making Betty feel obsolete; Amanda keeps a secret from Betty; Daniel discovers that his mother has a history with Cal Hartley.
Marital bliss turns into business, as the gang experiences the emotional and economic hardships of divorce.
Louis plans a romantic night -- at the car dealership -- for his and Jessica's wedding anniversary; Eddie receives help buying a hot-dog-shaped water slide.