Mike, Jen and Rich must decide if they are going to take on a 1735 Cape Cod with an off-center chimney and a stormy history or an 1830s Colonial home that is rumored to be the Old John Carver Inn.

The team restores an 1800s Cape Cod that's full of potential; also, the team digs into the history of a footlocker that may have been on the USS Constitution, and this unique garage sale find might be worth much more than the purchase price.

Mike, Jen and Rich help a couple renovate their 1666 Federalist-style home that's riddled with 350-year-old structural problems; they transform the untouched 1750s attic into dual bathrooms and add features to call out the home's original design.

Mike, Rich and Jen prepare for a big job as they consider two homes in different states of disrepair; one is a 1696 home that is literally leaning, and the other an 1800 home with a solid exterior that covers up the start of an abandoned demolition.