Paul B. Johnson

After Abbie's sister escapes from a psychiatric hospital, Ichabod helps Abbie search for her; Ichabod and Abbie learn more about the evil they are facing, including its name.

In the wake of the shooting, Earn and Alfred, aka Paper Boi, are arrested. While Alfred is released on bond, Earn remains in holding while he waits to be processed.

Fear is rampant in Sleepy Hollow when Pandora releases an artefact from her box that can transform the townsfolk into terrifying creatures.

The group deals with the fallout from the events that took place at the Centennial celebration; Roxy and Trevor are able to take Drew home; Denise and Roland suspect that David's friend is being abused; Gloria confides in Jackie.