Jimmy and Gretchen meet at a wedding and find themselves falling for each other despite their better judgment.

Jimmy freaks out when Gretchen inadvertently asks him for a key to his house; Jimmy finds out it's Gretchen's birthday.

Gretchen makes a reluctant Jimmy come over to her disaster of an apartment and he is judgmental of the mess.

Jimmy begrudgingly joins Gretchen, Edgar and Lindsay on the gang's weekly Sunday funday tradition or drinking and fun.