The BAU searches for three missing teenage girls when the mother of one of the missing asks for JJ's help.
After Booth's gun is taken away because he maliciously shot a clown ornament on an ice-cream truck, Brennan must go to Florida alone to investigate the death of a college student whose body is found inside an alligator.
The squad tries to solve a homicide case that is muddied by conflicting evidence; Maura must decide if she is going to take in her recently paroled grandfather; Jane and Casey must decide between their careers and their relationship.
Eric has a collision with actress Anna Faris; Turtle prepares for a party; Mrs. Ari reprises her role on a soap opera.
Kat challenges the status quo in the hope of championing new voices; Jane's response to a job posting sparks a difficult conversation with Kat about privilege; Sutton discovers something surprising about her latest fling.