Tracyraquel Berns untangles the web of lies behind her baby brother Matthew's death; with the help of experts and prosecutors, Berns exposes years of parental neglect, abuse and deception, revealing a haunting story of justice and perseverance.

After years, Matthew Golder's body is exhumed, and his death is ruled a homicide; his stepfather, Jan Barry Sandlin, is tried for murder; however, a technical error jeopardizes Tracyraquel Berns' fight for justice.

Jan Sandlin's second murder trial comes to an end, but doubts linger and questions about two other mysterious deaths remain; as Tracyraquel reflects on her journey, producers confront Sandlin and her mother Kathie Almon about past abuse she endured.