Mark and Andy return to Cavendish to visit their estranged father, who runs a tourist-trap museum out of his home. But as the brothers reacquaint themselves with their peculiar hometown, they get caught up in an ominous and threatening tradition.

On a whim, Mark and Andy join a production of Anne of Green Gables run by an unusual group of women known as The Annes. When they arrive to rehearse at a creepy, isolated manor, the brothers suspect the Annes have more sinister plans in mind.

In an attempt to impress his father, Andy adds a new exhibit featuring Canadian icon Fred Penner to the Museum. Mark tries to shut the exhibit down when Andy becomes dangerously obsessed by a mysterious statue.

When Mark wants to borrow money, Andy convinces him to get a job. But when Mark takes work in a travelling carnival, he risks getting sucked into a lifestyle from which he may never return.

While in town to see a show, Mark, Andy, and Molly get lost after dark in a dangerous Charlottetown neighbourhood. Now they have to run, hide and fight their way back to the tourist zone before they become victims of big-city crime.

Mark convinces Andy to join the local Coven with him to have some fun. But when Andy fits in better than Mark, the latter starts a much more sinister Coven, threatening to ruin Andy’s newfound group.