Jake and Annie are finally engaged after six years of dating, but her high-strung, larger-than-life personality and Jake’s laid-back approach to life will severely test the theory of “opposites attract.” They’ll soon understand that getting engaged was the easy part.

Jake moves into Annie's apartment, but Annie feels the stress of sharing her space with someone. Meanwhile, Gil discovers an all-you-can-eat buffet restaurant.

Annie and Jake set out to create a haunted house in their apartment for Halloween, but the trick's on them when a super-mom derails their plans. Elsewhere, Dennah hopes to impress at an exclusive party with her skimpy costume, and Gil and Kay spy on Gil's ex-wife.

A tornado warning that traps everyone to the basement raises questions about Annie (Casey Wilson) and Jake’s (Ken Marino) history of cursed first date anniversary celebrations.

Annie sets out to host Thanksgiving dinner, but tangles with Jake's mother, who's always hosted in the past. Elsewhere, Gil discovers he has a hidden skill for fine-cheese tasting.

Jake’s (Ken Marino) effort to get to know his future fathers-in-law reignites s a longstanding feud between the Kevins (Tim Meadows and Dan Bucatinsky). Annie (Casey Wilson) and Gil (John Gemberling) team up to write a song about Flemish pride.