In 2014, four women vanish from Chillicothe, Ohio, then two of the women are found dead, giving rise to fears of a serial killer; a fifth woman disappears in 2015, and another body is found.
While police search for the fifth missing woman, another body is found; police receive an anonymous tip pointing to a possible suspect; the fear of a serial killer haunts the community.
When two bodies are found in the same area one year apart, citizens wonder if the area could be a serial killer's dumping ground.
Police redouble their efforts to find a missing woman who turns out to have been friends with one of the murder victims; a person of interest is considered when the news of another missing girl sends the community into a panic.
The search for a pregnant 20-year-old woman ends while the search for another missing woman kicks into high gear.
Police chase down a terrifying new lead in a nearby town; Jason McCrary, accused of murdering Timberly Claytor, goes on trial.
Aurora Richards
Self
Alexandra Ivey
Grant Morningstar
Malcolm Simmons
Christopher Dillard
