The whole town attends the annual Scarecrow Festival, where cousins and best friends Kelly and Shrub compete in the festival events.

Kelly starts a ride-sharing business called "Kuber," and enlists Shrub as her business partner; Shrub seeks attention from Beth; Cheryl investigates the missing town sign.

When a coveted pair of sneakers lands in a Flatch shoe store, Kelly and Shrub come up with inventive ways to come up with the money to buy them, including selling homemade treasure maps and starting a for-profit hip-hop dance school.

Father Joe redirects Shrub's graffiti to an art class; Kelly gets some quality time with her father; Cheryl and Joe come to grips with their new relationship status.

Kelly inspires Dylan to return to his passion of magic with a visit to Flatch's new magic and vape shop, Smokus Pocus; Shrub finally takes Beth on a date.

Kelly and Shrub volunteer at a senior computer class and the town gets a lesson on catfishing; Mandy teaches Cheryl self-defense after she is attacked for her alliance with Pockton.