Oscar takes his love for Rey Mysterio too far humiliating Rey's opponent, Nicho. Uroboros transforms Nicho into a villain that can project horrible nightmares. Oscar then makes a mistake that leaves Rey alone against two powerful villains.

At a Lucha Libre convention a legendary championship belt is stolen. After an alliance between Rey Mysterio and Uroboros, Oscar leads the investigation trying to prove Dynamita is guilty, but there's more to this mystery than he suspects.