In 2014, four women vanish from Chillicothe, Ohio. When two are later found dead, fears of a serial killer mount when a fifth woman goes missing in 2015. Before police can fully investigate the fifth missing woman, another body is found.

While police search for the fifth missing woman, another body is found; police receive an anonymous tip pointing to a possible suspect; the fear of a serial killer haunts the community.

When two bodies are found in the same area one year apart, citizens wonder if the area could be a serial killer's dumping ground.

Police redouble their efforts to find a missing woman who turns out to have been friends with one of the murder victims; a person of interest is considered when the news of another missing girl sends the community into a panic.

The search for a pregnant 20-year-old woman ends while the search for another missing woman kicks into high gear.

Police chase down a terrifying new lead in a nearby town; Jason McCrary, accused of murdering Timberly Claytor, goes on trial.