In the series premiere, a thirty-something woman's life turns to chaos when an imaginary friend she created as a child returns after she begins dating a divorced father with three kids.

When Ben asks Alice to pick up Bunny from dance class, Mary learns that even simple parenting tasks have challenges; Andy enlists Alice's help to overcome his fear of taking a driving test.

Alice learns the emotional highs and lows of being a parent when Andy considers auditioning for the school musical; Dora creates her own feminist musical.

Andy struggles to find a prom date, while Dora repeatedly turns down a persistent suitor; Alice convinces Dora to go to the dance.

Ben's meeting with Alice's friends goes well despite her concerns; Ben makes a surprising confession.

Alice faces the dilemma of whether she should play the role of parent or friend as she tries to connect with Dora; Ben wants Alice to be his personal mole; Bunny infiltrates the one place Andy feels cool.