A love story in reverse; Jen thought she was getting a second chance with her college sweetheart, Spencer, but after watching him being led away in handcuffs, she realizes the man she married may be a monster.

Once Spencer is arrested, Jen deals with the aftermath of the accusation and makes a dark discovery about the former teacher of the year's extracurricular activities; numerous women say they have fallen victim to Spencer's manipulation and speak out.

Spencer's former student, Rachel, shares the story of sexual assault that led to his arrest, and other former students and colleagues discuss Spencer's disturbing behavior that went undetected; Jen tries to pick up the pieces of her shattered life.