Alison Louder

Hospital co-workers Aidan and Josh, who are also a vampire and a werewolf, rent a house from Danny, whose fiance Sally recently died. When the men move in, they discover Sally still lives there, as an amnesiac ghost which they can see because of their own non-human attributes. Aidan accidentally kills another co-worker, Rebecca, in the midst of passion. Bishop, a Boston police officer and the vampire that made Aidan, reveals that the police are looking to him as a suspect in Rebecca's disappearance. Josh encounters his sister Emily at the hospital, who hasn't seen him in the two years since he became a werewolf, which was shortly after she came out as a lesbian.

Aidan prevents Josh from harming his sister after being locked in a secured room with her while turning. Sally tries without avail to contact her fiance while he attempts to repair the apartment, but learns how she died. Aidan learns Rebecca has been turned by Bishop; he attempts to convince her not to feed, like him, but is rebuffed. Rebecca attacks Josh, and later their hospital coworker Cara.

Danny throws away Sally's engagement ring and it finds its way back to her, and she discovers it is an object that she can hold. Aidan is sent a DVD of Rebecca having sex with and then killing another man. Josh asks Nora out on a date, just as his sister Emily comes to him – she has broken up with her girlfriend Jackie and needs somewhere to stay. Aidan confronts Marcus and Rebecca about the DVD, but denies that he has feelings for her. Sally uses the ring to get revenge on Danny, but it only makes Danny hurt Bridget. Josh makes dinner for Nora, after getting Aidan, Sally, and Emily out of the house.

It has been a week since the events of the full moon. Sally is on edge as the Reaper has not sought her out to "shred" her, but he appears to her to give her an ultimatum as he has found a loophole. Sally can either be reaped or become the new Reaper. Josh has been out of work for the past week, in a slump since the breakup with Nora. Aidan, however, has called in Emily to cheer Josh up. When Sally asks Aidan for advice on the Reaper, he suggests she shred him before he gets the chance to shred her. Emily plans Josh's recovery from the breakup, saying that the two of them should go out drinking.

Josh resolves to kill Ray to save both himself and Nora from the werewolf curse while Aidan resolves to kill Mother so he and Suren may be together at last. Josh enlists Sally to possess Ray's wife, using her to call Ray out to a deserted stretch of road under the guise of fixing a flat tire. However, this act brings the Reaper entity back into Sally's mind. Once Ray arrives, Josh marches Ray out into the woods at gunpoint. Meanwhile, Aidan infiltrates Mother's coven and attempts to kill her and finds that Henry (who helped Aidan get inside) has been severely beaten and may be dead.