Hayden Maher

Ten unknowns compete for the role of a lifetime—the lead in a Hallmark Movie.

The remaining men are tested with a comedic improvisation challenge.

Nine unknowns compete in a Mr. December photoshoot with help from Tyler Hynes.

Six leading men perform at the Mr. Christmas talent show.

Brooke D'Orsay pairs up with our leading men for their latest acting challenge.

Witney Carson teaches the men dances to perform before a live audience.