Alicia and Peter have a bust up after she discovers the real reasons he has been taking the family to church. In court, Alicia fights against a grieving widow who is claiming that her husband was killed by Alicia's client.
Holmes and Watson get mixed up in murder and magic when they investigate the death of a magician killed while performing.
Bernard and Cosgrove are confronted with several suspects in the shooting of a headmaster at an elite private school; a teenager's life hangs in the balance as Price and Maroun debate who's more culpable -- the shooter or the enabler.
Danny and Baez think a girl has been kidnapped, but her mother denies it. Frank visits a priest who was arrested for a DUI.
A storm rages outside and a moody atmosphere gathers in the house. Oliver searches urgently for meaning in a centuries-old text.