Rebecca Avery

When Berta swears vengeance on the married man who got her daughter, Naomi (recurring guest star Sara Rue), pregnant, she forces Charlie to come with her. Meanwhile, Naomi helps Berta with the housework. And Alan reveals an unusual fetish.

In Buffalo, a serial killer sends a videotape depicting one of his crimes to the BAU. The content of the tape reveals clues and a message from the murderer by which he begs for help in stopping his rampage.

In the middle of the hurricane chaos, Underlay and Russell mount a rescue bid to free the humans captured by the hybrids, but two humans who suspect that Underlay is the cause of the chaos take Larkin, Dave, Jesse and Rose as hostages.