Now that they know who the Night Bandit is, the friends cook a spell that lets them see through the villain's eyes. Things get complicated when Darbie peers through Hannah's eyes and sees that something is troubling her at school.

Darbie attempts to solve Hannah's problems by cooking a karma spell, while Mama P has a revelation on her extended vacation. In the end, Hannah discovers she can handle her issues at school without the use of magic.

Hannah and Darbie throw a surprise birthday party for Kelly, who is distracted by the mystery of the Night Bandit and can't enjoy her own party. It turns out that Kelly may be keeping a secret of her own.

As they race to break the spell that is poisoning Kelly, Hannah and Darbie hope that they don't face yet another downside.

After an adventurous run, Kelly, Hannah and Darbie may have to make the ultimate sacrifice and say goodbye to the cookbook.

Just Add New Protectors: The magic cookbook has moved on to a new set of protectors in Bay City. Kelly, Hannah and Darbie help the new trio understand magic to help a wedding go ahead. (S3, ep 12)