As the workers of the North Pole celebrate a successful Christmas, Candy is shocked by the news that her boss at Santa Inc. has been poached by a big tech competitor. While her colleagues wonder who will be named as Santa's new successor, Candy considers the possibility of becoming the first female St. Nick in history.

A new year means a new batch of interns - leaving Candy juggling her ambitious goals with her role as mentor to doughy newcomer Devin. Then, Santa tasks Candy with delivering the annual State of the Workshop speech, but a shocking revelation soon causes Candy to question everything - including herself.

Still reeling from the aftermath of her ho-ho-horrible speech, Candy receives a job offer from Easter Enterprises that she'd be hopping mad not to take. Meanwhile, Cookie tries to catch up on lost sleep, while Santa relives his college days with a little help from Devin.

After Santa extends an invitation to the South Pole, Candy's attempts to bro out with the Board are thwarted by the arrival of Junior who will do anything to sleigh his way to the top of Santa's list. Meanwhile, Cookie and Goldie bond with a bored Mrs. Claus, and Craig crumbles at home.

As the big man's birthday nears, an increasingly cunning Candy prepares to roast her rivals. But just when it seems like Santa might finally name his successor, a shocking turn of events shakes up the competition. Meanwhile, friction with friends and family threatens to put a damper on the festivities.

As the citizens of the North Pole eagerly await the announcement of Santa's successor, Candy prepares for her calling - while continuing to clash with family and friends. Later, as a shocking revelation sends Santa Inc. reeling, Mrs. Claus makes a surprising decision, and Jingle Jim learns a saucy secret.