To get Mitch over a bad breakup, his best friend Charlie convinces him to come out with the guys. While Charlie is out getting beer, Mitch answers the door and is greeted by Wally, a man posing as a census taker who is in fact a serial killer about to strike again. In a crazy turn of events, Mitch accidentally stabs Wally before he can strike. Panic stricken and completely freaking out, Mitch, Charlie, and their stoner friend Jerry decide to prop Wally up like he is alive in order to get him out of the house and dispose of the body. But things go terribly wrong, and the group ends up getting chased by two dirty cops with Wally as part of their entourage.