On November 17th, 1990, two deer hunters are found shot dead in the woods of Michigan. Eleven-years later, cold case detectives arrest Jeff Titus on suspicion of the murders, but the original detectives on the case believe Titus is innocent.

A police officer comes under suspicion in the 1987 murder of an 11-year-old girl in Florida.

Three people are killed execution-style in a Louisiana convenience store.

In 1997, a grandmother is found murdered in her Florida apartment. Family members spend the next 15 years suspecting one of their own kin is responsible.