Ben is out for his usual morning jog when he comes upon the body of young Tom Murphy. After the news begins to spread throughout town, Detective Cornell, who's been assigned to the case, pays Ben a visit for routine questioning. In the blink of an eye, Ben quickly turns from Good Samaritan to murder suspect.

Ben investigates the people closest to Tom after receiving news about the case; Tom's mother suspects her estranged husband might be the killer.

After a surprising public revelation, Ben struggles to keep his family together -- and maintain his innocence.

Ben makes a discovery that prompts him to confront Vanessa and Joseph Richardson; Cornell drops another bombshell on Ben.

While trying to help his neighbor's son, Ben finds an important piece of evidence that is related to Tom's murder and leads him to suspect the Daly family of wrongdoing; a new threat emerges in Ben's life.

When his stalker ups the ante, Ben begrudgingly accepts Detective Cornell's offer of protection for his family but refuses police surveillance for himself; Ben moves in with Dave and starts to think he's escaped Cornell's focus.