After a sex worker is found brutally murdered at a local high school, police uncover a Satanic cult and a sadistic pimp, Carl Drew. As detectives race to secure the testimony of a witness, she becomes the next victim.

Satan takes a prominent role in the bizarre 1981 trial of Carl Drew, as the “Satanic Panic” incites fear across the country. Carl’s claims of innocence are overlooked, leading to a shocking injustice.

Through a prison interview, Robin Murphy’s harrowing account brings everything into question. Her story paints a picture of corruption and neglect that reveals a truth never before considered.

While Carl Drew appeals his case, a new witness is discovered who describes one of the murders, and the filmmakers return to meet with Robin Murphy a final time.