Karly Rothenberg

Karly Rothenberg is an American film and television actress. Rothenberg is best known for her roles as warehouse worker Madge “Pudge” Madsen on The Office and Ms. Erin Shapiro in the Netflix mockumentary American Vandal. She played Marlene, the secretary to Lt. Felix Valdez on the Lifetime series The Protector. She also had a recurring role as Mrs. Valentine on That's So Raven.

Grey's Anatomy · S8, E3

Take the Lead

The chief makes a decision that shocks everyone at Seattle Grace; Owen and Cristina attempt to find normalcy; April struggles in her new role; the fifth-year residents receive their first solo surgery assignments.
The Office · S6, E13

Secret Santa

Michael is outraged when Jim lets Phyllis be Santa at the office Christmas party; Jim and Dwight try to get everyone in the holiday spirit; Oscar has a secret crush.
The Office · S5, E24

Heavy Competition

Dwight's devotion to Michael is tested; Andy tries to fulfill Jim's emotional needs.
Criminal Minds · S9, E8

The Return

The team searches for missing teens who are suspects in a series of mass murders in Chicago.
Desperate Housewives · S7, E1

Remember Paul?

Paul Young, now out of prison, returns to Wisteria Lane with an enigmatic new wife; Susan, Mike and M.J. live in an apartment on limited funds; Lynette's successful college friends pay the Scavos an unexpected visit.
Grotesquerie · S1, E6

Good Caesarean Work

A new discovery leads Lois to someone from her past.

Karly Rothenberg

Guest Appearances