Bill Suplee

Marshall and Lily worry that Lily will never fall pregnant. To allay their fears, the couple visit a specialist who bears an uncanny resemblance to Barney.

Earl tries to repair his broken relationship with his father, as he nominates him for mayor. Earl chooses to re-nominate him after accidentally messing up his chances of winning the last time he ran for the position.

Earl becomes offended when he is not invited to Joy's wedding, which falls on his birthday. He ends up becoming drunk and crashing the party, breaking Joy's nose in the process.

Earl uncovers some skeletons in the old family closet while trying to woo back his parents' old friends; Joy dupes One-Eyed Willy out of his glass eye and refuses to return it.

Earl tries to make up for sabotaging a cat show to increase Joy's chances of winning. He attempts to return a prize-winning cat, only to find that Randy is interested in its owner.

Randy takes Catalina's nephew under his wing, fearing he may be capable of conjuring dark magic; Earl plans a Halloween party for Dodge and Earl Jr.