It is Peter's birthday and his friends want to make sure it is the best. They make up a story about treasure but the pirates beat them to the top of the hill to get it.

Michael has a nightmate that the Lost Boys go missing, but it comes true so Peter and the Darlings must save them.

Michael runs away and bumps into Smee, they are both upset. They talk infront of the Murmuring Make a Wish Tree and realise they must now save Wendy and Hook.

When Hook gets hit on the head he starts to act like a child which cheers Wendy up when nothing else will.

John is really interested in the story of Long John Pepper, who had a very powerful sword and hid it in the most dangerous place in Neverland, the cursed swamp.