Juan Pope

Jimmy's life takes a drastic turn when he finds out that his one-night stand, is a wanted felon. Months later, when Jimmy pays a visit to the prison, he discovers that Lucy gave birth to their baby, who he is now charged with raising.

Jimmy offers to attend the deli guy's Halloween party in Sabrina's boyfriend's place. Meanwhile, a box of videos from prison arrives and Jimmy must decide whether or not to let Hope see them.

Cousin Mike visits with his new wife and three brother-husbands; Burt tries to fix his brother's relationship with Mike.

With Randy's birthday coming up, Earl gets him a new car, but the car is stolen before Earl can even present it to Randy. Apparently this means that Earl no longer falls under the code of criminals, which states that no thief can steal from another. Now that Earl is treated as a `civilian', he needs to decide whether to take the matter of the theft of Randy's birthday present to the police, or become a snitch.

Darnell and Joy have to go into the witness protection program, but Joy isn't happy with her new identity: Phyllis Rosenstein from Ohio. Meanwhile, Earl and Randy try to post themselves in a crate to Joy and Darnell's new home to make up for spoiling Joy's chance of being famous.

While comatose Earl is still living in his fantasy sitcom world - where his wife Billie announces she is pregnant - Randy tries to atone for the time he and Earl stole a motorbike. However, they were so drunk that Randy can't remember exactly what they did, and his investigations lead to a disturbing revelation.