Danny tries to build bridges with Riley after their recent break-up, but she is still furious after learning he hooked up with Sam in high school. Determined to prove that she's not overreacting, Riley puts Danny on `trial' for breaking her heart.
Riley faints after Danny asks her to marry him, and when she wakes up, she has no memory of his proposal. Trying to move on from Riley, Ben decides to find `his Riley' and straight away hits it off with new neighbour Zoey.
Tucker finds Zoey snooping around his apartment and assumes she is there for him, so he takes it upon himself to ask her out. However, Zoey believes Tucker is setting her up with Ben.