Elmer's transition out of the Amish leads to an unsavory addiction; Laurie struggles with the pressures of converting to Orthodox Judaism; Ashley sets out to ease the tension between her conservative Catholic family and her Muslim husband.

Kris grapples with his family's disapproval of his girlfriend's religion.

Tensions rise when Kris's dad pushes salvation onto Lensa.

Mohammed confronts Ashley's sister, and Eli and Laurie butt heads.

Lindsey and Elmer head into Amish country to reconcile with his family.

Mohammed gives Ashley an ultimatum, tensions rise at Eli and Laurie's housewarming party, and Kris is faced with a life-changing decision.