When a beloved teenager suddenly goes missing, the quiet neighborhood of Happy Hollow is turned upside down; a local high school metal band goes from being invisible to being grist for the gossip mill and becoming the hottest ticket in town.

Dylan's interview with Chief Dandridge reveals a development in the missing person's case; Faith and Linda question their recent experiences; suspicion toward the Dethkrunch trio grows as all of Happy Hollow gathers for an event at the church.

Dethkrunch puts in the work to host their first official Satanic cult meeting; Faith conducts her own investigation; Linda seeks to connect with anyone who could understand what she's going through.

Ahead of Homecoming, Dylan and Judith make their relationship official despite Jordy and Spud's hesitations; Chief Dandridge questions local suspects; Faith attempts normalcy for a night.

A week before Ryan's disappearance, a budding romance forms between him and Faith, but when Tracy hears rumors of her daughter's love life, she must take drastic measures to stop her from making the same mistakes she did as a teen in 1969.

When Chief Dandridge's cult suspicions are confirmed, Dylan and the other members become the center of his investigation; Linda fears she is losing herself after a shocking confrontation; Faith struggles to play her part with Tracy and the Reverend.